U.S. Appeals Court Delays Corporate Transparency Act Deadline
The 5th U.S. Circuit Court has blocked the Corporate Transparency Act, delaying the deadline for businesses to report their owners to the Treasury Department.
A federal appeals court has halted the implementation of the Corporate Transparency Act (CTA), a law requiring businesses to disclose their beneficial owners to the U.S. Treasury Department. The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reinstated a nationwide injunction late Thursday, pausing enforcement just weeks before the original January 13 deadline for most companies.
Judge Declares Transparency Law Unconstitutional
The legal dispute began when U.S. District Judge Amos Mazzant in Texas ruled earlier this month that the CTA violated constitutional limits. In his December 3 decision, Judge Mazzant argued that Congress lacked the authority to pass the law under commerce, tax, and foreign affairs powers. He also cited the Tenth Amendment, stating the law infringed on states’ rights and labeled the measure as “quasi-Orwellian.”
Appeals Court Restores Injunction Amid Constitutional Concerns
After the U.S. Department of Justice briefly succeeded in getting the injunction lifted, the appeals court reinstated it, stating that enforcement should remain paused while the case is under review. The court emphasized the need to “preserve the constitutional status quo” as a different panel considers the substantive legal arguments presented by both sides.
Advertisement
Small Businesses Fight Back Against Reporting Mandate
The injunction was secured by the National Federation of Independent Business and several small businesses, represented by the Center for Individual Rights. Critics of the CTA argue it imposes intrusive surveillance and unnecessary burdens on smaller enterprises.
“This type of government overreach should not be allowed,” said Todd Gaziano, president of the Center for Individual Rights. “Small businesses deserve to have their privacy protected while the courts determine the law’s constitutionality.”
Supporters Warn of Financial Crime Risks
Passed in 2021, the CTA requires corporations and LLCs to submit detailed ownership information to the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN). Proponents of the law argue it is essential for combating money laundering, tax evasion, and other illicit activities. Without these requirements, supporters claim, criminals can easily use shell companies to hide their activities.
The delay has sparked concern among advocates for stronger financial transparency. They warn that pausing enforcement could allow criminals to exploit the gaps the law was designed to address.
Businesses Await Final Decision
For now, companies are relieved of the obligation to meet the January deadline for reporting ownership details to FinCEN. However, the legal battle continues, with a final decision yet to be made on the CTA’s future.
This case underscores a larger debate over the balance between federal oversight and constitutional protections, with both sides arguing for fundamental rights and responsibilities in a changing financial landscape.
Also Read: Bank of America Acquires $990M Multifamily Loan Portfolio from HomeStreet
