Amazon Sues NLRB Over Alleged Unconstitutional Practices and Election Influence

San Antonio, TX — Amazon has initiated a federal lawsuit against the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), contending that the agency’s structure is unconstitutional and that it improperly influenced the outcome of a union election at one of its warehouses. The complaint was filed in a San Antonio federal court on Thursday.

The lawsuit, which builds on earlier arguments presented by Amazon this year, alleges that the NLRB’s actions unfairly swayed the results of a union vote held at Amazon’s Staten Island warehouse in March 2022. The tech giant claims that the NLRB's legal move to reinstate a union organizer shortly before the election constituted undue interference in the voting process, which resulted in the warehouse’s successful unionization.

Amazon’s complaint also takes issue with the NLRB’s organizational structure. The company argues that the same NLRB members who authorized an injunction against Amazon were also responsible for reviewing the objections related to the election. Amazon asserts that this arrangement violates constitutional principles because these board members are shielded from removal by the President, thereby undermining Amazon’s due process rights.

This legal action is part of a broader trend of challenges against the NLRB by major corporations. Companies such as SpaceX and Trader Joe’s have similarly questioned the board’s decisions and structural integrity. These disputes underscore ongoing conflicts between large enterprises and regulatory bodies overseeing labor practices.

The NLRB has defended its practices, citing a Supreme Court ruling from 1937 that upheld the board’s constitutionality. Kayla Blado, a spokesperson for the NLRB General Counsel, remarked that while these lawsuits can cause delays, they do not ultimately impact the enforcement of labor laws. Jennifer Abruzzo, NLRB General Counsel, has suggested that these legal challenges are tactics used by companies to evade compliance with labor regulations.

The outcome of Amazon’s lawsuit could have significant repercussions for labor relations and regulatory practices. A ruling in Amazon’s favor might prompt changes in the management of labor disputes and the operational structure of labor boards. This case highlights the ongoing debate over workers' rights and corporate accountability in the evolving landscape of U.S. labor law.

Also Read: Amazon Aims for $5 Billion in Exports from India by 2024, Moving Away from China