Google Requests Court to Delay App Store Changes, Cites Security Risks

Google has requested a federal judge in California to temporarily halt a recent court ruling that would force changes to its Play Store, allowing more competition. The company hopes to delay the ruling while it appeals the decision, arguing that these changes could lead to significant security risks.

Ad

In a filing made last Friday, Google explained that U.S. District Judge James Donato’s order, which is set to go into effect on November 1, could create "serious safety, security, and privacy risks" for the Android operating system. Google, which is part of Alphabet Inc., is asking the judge to pause the order until the appeal process is completed.

The Ruling and Google’s Concerns

Judge Donato issued the order on October 7 in response to a lawsuit filed by Epic Games, the maker of "Fortnite." Last year, a jury agreed with Epic Games that Google was unfairly controlling how users download apps on Android devices and make in-app purchases. The court determined that Google was using its position to limit competition.

Advertisement

Under the judge's ruling, Google must allow Android users to download apps from third-party stores and use alternative payment methods for in-app purchases. Additionally, Google can no longer pay device manufacturers to pre-install its Play Store or share its Play Store revenue with other app distributors.

Google believes that these changes could expose users to security and privacy threats, as allowing third-party stores and payment systems could make it easier for malicious apps to reach Android devices. The company has built its ecosystem around strict security standards and warns that the court's decision could undermine this system.

What Google Plans to Do Next

Google has already filed its appeal with the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco. If Judge Donato denies Google’s request to pause the ruling, the company plans to ask the appeals court to intervene.

The appeals process will likely take time, and Google hopes that the Play Store changes won’t go into effect while the case is being reviewed.

Background of the Lawsuit

Epic Games, known for its popular game "Fortnite," has been leading the charge against what it views as monopolistic practices by major tech companies like Google and Apple. Epic claims that these companies are making it difficult for developers to reach users without paying hefty fees for access to their app stores and payment systems.

Epic Games filed similar lawsuits against both Google and Apple, arguing that these companies’ app store rules stifle competition and unfairly raise costs for both developers and users. Last year, Epic successfully convinced a jury that Google’s control over the Play Store and in-app payments violated antitrust laws.

The judge's recent ruling is a significant win for Epic Games, as it aims to open up the Android app market to more competition.

What This Means for Users and Developers

If the court order stands, Android users could see significant changes in how they download apps and make purchases within apps. Users might have more choices, such as being able to use different app stores or payment methods that could potentially offer lower fees or better deals.

For developers, this could mean reduced costs for distributing apps and more flexibility in how they accept payments from users. Many developers have long argued that Google's Play Store fees, which can be as high as 30%, make it harder for them to succeed in the marketplace.

However, there are concerns that opening the Android ecosystem to third-party stores could increase the risk of malicious apps and lower overall security for users.

What's Next for Google's Play Store?

As the legal battle continues, Google is striving to defend its Play Store policies. The company claims that its current system ensures security and privacy for users and developers. However, critics argue that Google's control over the app market stifles competition.

The outcome of this case could have a wide-ranging impact, not just for Android users and developers but for other tech companies as well. The court's decision on Google's appeal will shape how apps are distributed and paid for on Android devices in the future.

For now, all attention is focused on the upcoming rulings, which could potentially change the mobile app ecosystem.

Also Read: U.S. DOJ Proposes Actions to Challenge Google's Search Dominance